Verdict: No

Do the famous TradingView indicators beat buy-and-hold?

0 of 15

on SPY, 10 years, textbook rules

MACD, Bollinger, SuperTrend, Ichimoku, RSI, Stochastic, ADX, Parabolic SAR, Donchian, Keltner, CCI, Williams %R, MFI, OBV and the golden cross — on SPY over 10 years, none of them beat simply holding. On TSLA only MACD did. You can run this on any ticker for free on the home page.

Tested on: Daily prices, 15 indicators with their standard textbook rules, costs included · Published: 2026-07-28

The receipts

The receipts are for members

1 sections · the year-by-year numbers, the failed variants, and why. $19/month, cancel anytime.

Join the Library

Already a member? Sign in

Want your own strategy tested like this?

Describe it in plain English (Arabic is fine). We run it on the same real data and send you a verdict page like this one within 48 hours.

Test my strategy · $79